Early in Tony Gilroy’s Behemoth! we follow cellist Alex Serian (Pascal) running out of a glitzy, money fueled concert hall into a dim, snowy Chicago night as a flees the lover who has just learned he’s leaving town. It’s a breathtaking image, gathering the different aspects of the film into a compact whole, from the way the moneyed world these messy musicians’ flit in and out of to the constant relationship dramatics they both instigate and flee from like vagabond minstrels with no sense of home or roots. It’s richly thematic and cinematically interesting in its execution. Unfortunately, as a film it tends to share its hero’s habit of slipping away from the hard parts.
It’s made much easier that there is seemingly no lack of suitors for Alex’s services, either as a lover or a musician, due to his great artistic skill and acumen. A third-generation musician and cello prodigy in his own right, Alex has been playing at such a high level that whenever he feels the siren call he can jump from the Dallas Symphony to Chicago to a Los Angeles scoring stage for film work after a relationship goes bad and his mother enters hospice care there. Bouncing back and forth through his past, particularly the part that surrounds his brief, tumultuous relationship with equally talented violinist Nadia (Victor) sixteen years before, and the long, tortured road that brought him back to his family and the home he grew up in. Waiting on the other end of that could be the foundation and roots that have eluded him since his parent’s divorce (and probably since his musician father’s control over his early training and ambition) but only if he can face all of those painful memories once and for all.
At it’s best Behemoth! is exactly the clever and engrossing character drama that description sounds like. It’s also some of Gilroy’s most purely cinematic work of his directorial career, as he takes chances on something other than dialogue to move his work around. Building around a central conceit of Alex’s scoring session work (contributed by a murderer’s row of the best composers in Hollywood including Michael Giacchino, James Newton Howard, Alan Silvestri and more), Gilroy builds Alex’s various misadventures alongside the music he is playing at any given moment, transforming his life into whatever genre that may be, whether that is slapstick farce against a familial argument or an ill-considered mansion invasion transformed into thrilling escape as an action score plays in the background. Whether he realizes it or not, Alex really is the star of his own story.
Mostly he doesn’t realize it; mostly he actively tries not to realize it. The device puts Alex’s passivity on screen; he never chooses the register of his own life, it always chooses for him in a blend of pathos and farce he never quite escapes no matter how hard he tries. Particularly whenever his younger, not quite as talented brother Andy (Arnett) enters the picture to give Alex a particularly clear example of how getting married and settling down likely would have worked out for him. It gives Pascal some of the most difficult work of his career as he builds his character out of reaction, making a closed-off man readable without giving him the option (or ability) to really explain himself. That tends to be left to the murderer’s row of character actors and supporting players Gilroy has surrounded him with, giving each scene the acting version of a session musician’s magic touch and creating life where Gilroy frequently just gestures at it.
Like a modern Turning Point, Behemoth! is a little bit too beholden to its conceit and unsure of what it wants to say. Alex’s penchant for escape allows him to avoid catharsis as much as possible which means we avoid. Which wouldn’t be so bad if the film itself wasn’t regularly doing the same, finding quick solutions to difficult, intractable problems in order to get them off the board and let Alex move on to whatever is left. It’s a quiet, somewhat sad end to what was an engrossing symphony as it tends to keep leaving the room just before the music resolves. It’s a good movie, still, but in its best scenes we can hear a great one.
7.5 out of 10
Starring Pedro Pascal, Olivia Wilde, Eva Victor, Alexa Swinton, Will Arnett, JoBeth Williams and Stephanie Sigman. Directed by Tony Gilroy.