Nitesh Tiwari promised a big screen, big budget adaptation of the Ramayana that could stand alongside any tentpole release of the studio system and he has certainly delivered that and everything that comes with it. A sumptuous visible feast of color and design, it brings the world of the classic epic to life in a swirl of exposition and set pieces and relatively flat characterization that leave it of a piece with the Avengers and Star Wars’s of the world. Some of that is a side effect of being an adaptation of one of the most famous epics of world literature, which tends to benefit from slavish replication of classic moments rather than interrogation of themes or characters. As that sort of adaptation, it is vaunted success; as an action film in its own right, it tends to be a little hollow.
Some of that comes one of the few derivations the story takes early, which creates unexpected weakness as it goes. Offering up context for the complex story elements to come, this first half of a planned two part adaptation starts well before its primary action, following the defeat of the Brahmins at the hands of Indra, a defeat which pushes young prince Ravana (Yash) to give up his dreams of music and reforge his people into a weapon of war who can throw off Indra’s yoke to take control of the Earth for himself and his humanity. His arrogance and might is needed to encourage Vishnu to reappear as a new avatar in the shape of prince Ram (Kapoor), a valiant archetype of what mankind may aspire to but who nevertheless is banished to wander in the forest in the poems most well-known moment, while Ravana continues to expand his influence and increasingly terrorize those around him as his passions take deeper control of him.
And that’s only the beginning. Ramayana is packed so full of entrances, exits, strange creatures and action sequences three hours is still only enough to house the beginning of the story, leaving it stopping at roughly halfway through the poem (and leaving a to be stuffed into the second part). It moves a speedy pace, with scenes rarely allowed for silence or introspection, preferring more for heightened emotion and a constant blaring soundtrack from Oscar winner Hans Zimmer. Piecemeal it can be fantastically entertaining in the way a Marvel film can be, albeit with the same drawbacks particularly the plastiky sheen of those kinds of films and the unavoidable feeling of many people standing in front of a green screen. You can watch it, but you may not ever be able to believe in it.
Plenty of big movies are just like that (and this is just like plenty of those movies) but its stronger weaknesses actually stem from the source material and how it interacts with it. It keeps faith with how the epic conceives of its two great opponents, Ram as the embodiment of virtue and Ravana as rage and passion. Thematically that’s understable, offering Ram as a model for people to uphold, but it creates a hero who not only never does anything wrong, but who never fails. He never even seems to sweat, even in the densest action. Those kinds of decent do-gooders, those Superman’s and Captain America’s, can be difficult to relate to or humanize and Ram suffers mightily from that, particularly in comparison to Ravana who has been recontextualized from a demon to man – is ten heads rethought as his inner personalities pushing him this way and that. Yash is tremendous in the role, making Ravana not only the interesting person on screen most of the time but frequently the de facto protagonist in a way the story just won’t allow for. The resulting tension is less ironic and more deflating, leaving an unprepared viewer wondering why they’re not just following Ravana, and robbing the epic’s most famous moments of some of their dramatic power.
There’s still quite a bit left to squeeze in to the second half as Ram and Ravana do not interact once in the first, and several of the story’s most iconic characters have not even appeared yet. From the experience of the first film the second is likely to be even more stuffed to the gills, but it’s hard to say how heart of the story will work spread across so many parts and hours. The spectacle will all be there. Whether anything is going on beneath it is still a question.
6 out of 10
Starring Ranbir Kapoor, Yash, Sai Pallavi, Ravi Dubey, Arun Govil, Anupam Kher and Lara Dutta. Directed by Nitesh Tiwari.